ive seen all the seasons. its unanimous s1 is GOAT. i never thought s2 was that bad, it was just OK if anything, but i rewatched it recently after watching s3 and i think it is just as good as s1. which is a lot considering i thing s1 is some of the best television ever. and im about to dump a giant essay on TRUDETECTIVE cuz its been on my mind a lot lately. this is the only communal website i visit so im purging
i need to rewatch s3 to garner more thorough thoughts, but i think s3 is by far the worst one. i classify it what i would call a âtrans showâ - its soul is stuck in the body of a show that is completely disparate from its purpose. i.e. the show is trying to have a romantic, poignant, beguiling aura but fails when its in the body of a show based on grit, vice, and investigation
the âaction scenesâ are about as tense as a friends episode, the show spends way too much time on the case and investigating clues that really dont reflect the direction the show goes, has too many self referential red herrings that are only explicit to the eyes of someone with knowing previous seasons. one of the best thing true detective does is making 8 episodes about as fulfilling as 5 seasons, with continuous progression and memorable scenes that make episodes stick out. all i remember is the native american kamikaze and getting picked up by spooky hoyt, both of which are the tense âclimaxesâ of the show and are disney compared to other seasons in terms of excitement and tension
i could go on with things like that, but about the âtrans shellâ its fitting into, one thing i was continuously bothered by is how these characters are always speaking in that low 2010s acting rasp (that i think well all retrospectively look back as being particular to this cultures era) but its supposed to be a drama based on emotions that arent completely based on pain and sin as per past seasons. people dont speak or act like that when talking to lovers, friends and whatever. its annoying as hell and even velcoro in s2 had more inflection in his cadence than mahaershaâs character
without ranting too hard on the next thing, s2 i think is an incredibly weaved complex web of power, ethics, and relationships that, like s1âs magic, reflect so aptly the environment that conquers the season. its criminal how panned it is, i need a lawyer